Zeldin Monologue

This letter to the editor was published in the East Hampton Star on March 9, 2017.


Thank you for this paper’s coverage of our congressman, Lee Zeldin. It is reassuring to know the press is holding Zeldin accountable, even as he hides from his constituents.

Since Zeldin took office on Jan. 3, his constituents have visited his offices weekly and placed hundreds if not thousands of calls to his offices demanding a public town hall. Those calls have been echoed by many of the First Congressional District’s news organizations, from Smithtown Matters to The Suffolk Times to this newspaper, to name just a few.

Zeldin’s claim that telephone town halls and mobile office hours are more effective ways to respond to his constituents is laughable. During Zeldin’s recent hourlong call with his constituents, he answered the questions (prescreened by his staff) of only 12 callers or less than .13% of the people on the call. In sum, it was a Zeldin monologue, not the “constructive dialogue,” he promised. Zeldin’s mobile office hours held last Friday in Patchogue turned out to be another sham alternative to a town hall. Billed as an opportunity to meet with Zeldin, the event attracted hundreds of constituents. As on the telephone call, aides first screened constituents’ concerns. But after waiting hours many never had a chance to meet with Zeldin. Most were relegated to meeting with his staff. Others left in frustration.

If Zeldin respected his entire district and took seriously his role as a representative in a democracy, he would hold a town hall. In that kind of forum, representatives listen to the unscreened concerns of a large number of constituents, and those constituents have the valuable opportunity to learn what issues are of importance to each other. It is a foundational civic practice dating back to our early settlers.

Zeldin’s fear that a town hall might be disrupted is no justification for his refusal to hold one. First, his claims of aggressive behavior at an East Patchogue rally were grossly exaggerated. Second, as other G.O.P. congressmen have had the courage to face unhappy constituents, why can’t Zeldin? And, finally, if Zeldin is concerned that the crowd won’t observe the proper decorum, he should follow the suggestion made by several grass-roots organizations and ask a neutral third party to moderate.

It’s simple, Congressman Zeldin. You wanted this job. Now do it.

Yours truly,

AMY TURNER,  Wainscott, East Hampton, NY



This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Zeldin Monologue

  1. amyturner2000 says:

    When he spoke to members of an activist group a couple of weeks ago, he referred to ONE comment made in a moveon petition with hundreds of signatures. I looked at it and while certainly unacceptable, the four-word comment hardly seemed like a credible threat. I googled the person who made the comment and author seemed to be an older resident of the district whose name I didn’t recognize. (He said he reported it to the police) I’m afraid he’s exaggerating this threat just as he did the supposed “violence” at an East Patchogue rally. (The police were present at the rally at the organizers’ request and saw no problems, and the press who was also present reported no incidents….). In my view, he is looking for any excuse to avoid having to answer unscreened questions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s